Showing posts with label science. Show all posts
Showing posts with label science. Show all posts

Monday, March 2, 2015

Author Ian McEwan - "There are ways of being wrong that help others to be right"

From "This Idea Must Die: Scientific Theories That Are Blocking Progress" by John Brockman, a collection of answers from famous scientists and thinkers to the question: "What scientific idea is ready for retirement?" This response is from British writer Ian McEwan:

Beware of arrogance! Retire nothing! A great and rich scientific tradition should hang onto everything it has. Truth is not the only measure. There are ways of being wrong that help others to be right. Some are wrong, but brilliantly so. Some are wrong but contribute to method. Some are wrong but help found a discipline. Aristotle ranged over the whole of human knowledge and was wrong about much. But his invention of zoology alone was priceless. Would you cast him aside? You never know when you might need an old idea. It could rise again one day to enhance a perspective the present cannot imagine.


[Hat Tip Brain Pickings]

Wednesday, May 28, 2014

Scientific American urges drug companies to release all clinical trial data

We've advocated over and over again for groups involved in experiments to release all data and results from those experiments - even those that don't succeed. "Dark data" can open up new areas of discovery and illuminate unforeseen issues with "safe" products.

Now, Scientific American magazine is taking up the cause. An article in its June issue, "Secret Clinical Trial Data To Go Public," discusses drug companies' reluctance to share any results that don't support their marketing efforts, and suggests how to open things up. The editors write:

How well does a prescription drug work? It can be hard for even doctors to know. Pharmaceutical companies frequently withhold the results of negative or inconclusive trials. Without a full accounting, a physician who wants to counsel a patient about whether a drug works better than a sugar pill is frequently at a loss. Drug companies share only airbrushed versions of data on safety and usefulness.

The editors go on to recommend drug trial information be published in an open data system akin to Yale's cleverly-named YODA project. Our hope is that big pharma jumps in whole-heartedly. Science and health-care patients present and future (that would be all of us) need it.

Thursday, November 7, 2013

Mistake Bank Bookshelf: "Brilliant Blunders" by Marco Livio - the consequences of scientific mistakes

This week's entry in the bookshelf is Brilliant Blunders: From Darwin to Einstein - Colossal Mistakes by Great Scientists That Changed Our Understanding of Life and the Universe, by Marco Livio.

Livio profiles the work of Charles Darwin, Lord Kelvin, Linus Pauling, Albert Einstein and Fred Hoyle. A greater roster of 19th and 20th century scientists would be difficult to create. Livio first sketches out the subject's research, then examines a large mistake each made. These stories don't follow the typical inventor narrative - where the scientist makes a mistake and then, by overcoming it or following where it leads, achieves a breakthrough. In each case, the mistakes either follow or sit alongside a breakthrough. They are significant and frequently held onto tenaciously by the scientist, even in the face of evidence to the contrary. One blunder, Einstein's concept for a cosmological constant, was accepted (especially given its esteemed author), then discredited by evidence of an expanding universe and has, lately, somewhat come back into fashion. If you want to learn about how complex and convoluted scientific progress can be, read this: "Why Einstein Was Wrong About Being Wrong."

My favorite section of Brilliant Blunders concerns Linus Pauling's attempts to decode the structure of DNA - the major scientific race of the 1950s. Pauling, the most honored chemist in the first half of the 20th century, was widely expected to solve the mystery of genetic reproduction. We all know how that story ended. There are traces of the Innovator's Dilemma in Pauling's story - too tied to the theories that made his reputation, and complacent, he was outflanked by a nimbler, disruptive competitor (Crick and Watson and the frequently neglected Rosalind Franklin). There are lots of lessons in Pauling's story about how our biases contribute to mistakes. And I've never read a pithier postmortem review:

Pauling's wife, Ava Helen, asked him after all the hoopla surrounding the Watson and Crick model had subsided: "If that was such an important problem, why didn't you work harder on it?"

Possibly the greatest message from Brilliant Blunders is that scientific progress (indeed much important progress) requires competition, collaboration and dialogue (for more on this, see one of my favorite books, Smart World). Each of the scientists, despite his genius, made significant mistakes that, if unchallenged, would have greatly slowed the advance of their fields of study. Instead, others disputed, probed and created alternative explanations that, in combination with the breakthroughs from the "blundering" giants, provided a much greater understanding of our world.

Thursday, August 1, 2013

Free the "dark data" from scientific failures

I recently stumbled across "Freeing the Dark Data of Failed Scientific Experiments," by Thomas Goetz in Wired magazine. I had read it years ago, and its thesis still sounds as fresh today as it did back in 2007:

What happens to all the research that doesn't yield a dramatic outcome — or, worse, the opposite of what researchers had hoped? It ends up stuffed in some lab drawer. The result is a vast body of squandered knowledge that represents a waste of resources and a drag on scientific progress. This information — call it dark data — must be set free.

While the usefulness of negative data is being recognized, there are still powerful forces, organizational and human, working against freeing our dark data:

More and more, research is funded by commercial entities, which deem any results proprietary. And even among fair-minded academics, the pressures of time, tender, and tenure can make openness an afterthought. If their research is successful, many academics guard their data like Gollum, wringing all the publication opportunities they can out of it over years. If the research doesn't pan out, there's a strong incentive to move on, ASAP, and a disincentive to linger in eddies that may not advance one's job prospects.

One of the publications cited by Goetz is still going strong: "The Journal of Negative Results in BioMedicine," edited by Bjorn Olsen of Harvard Medical School, has possibly the most delicious description of any journal ever:

Journal of Negative Results in BioMedicine is an open access, peer-reviewed, online journal that promotes a discussion of unexpected, controversial, provocative and/or negative results in the context of current tenets.

When will all the results of scientific research be released into the wild? How can we free up this unused resource?

Thursday, December 27, 2012

"We must learn to love uncertainty and failure"

This is from the 15 Jan 2011 edition of the Guardian. Not brand-new, but the message is still current:

"We must learn to love uncertainty and failure, say leading thinkers"

Being comfortable with uncertainty, knowing the limits of what science can tell us, and understanding the worth of failure are all valuable tools that would improve people's lives, according to some of the world's leading thinkers.

The ideas were submitted as part of an annual exercise by the web magazine Edge, which invites scientists, philosophers and artists to opine on a major question of the moment. This year it was, "What scientific concept would improve everybody's cognitive toolkit?"

The magazine called for "shorthand abstractions" – a way of encapsulating an idea or scientific concept into a short description that could be used as a component of bigger questions.

You can read the rest of the piece here.

Hat tip to David Cancel.

Tuesday, August 7, 2012

Web site offers scientists access to lessons from failed experiments

The New York Times Bits blog profiled the website ResearchGate, which gathers lessons from failed scientific experiments and makes them available to other researchers:

“Science is very inefficient,” says Ijad Madisch, founder of a Web site called ResearchGate. “You try an experiment, fail, try again, fail, try again, it works. And what works is what you publish. All the data about failure is wasted.”

Begun in 2008, ResearchGate claims to have 11,000 research and educational institutions among its users. It aims to be a place where people can share what they learned in the failed experiments. Some of this is documented, but a great deal more takes place across chat rooms where scientists informally exchange information.

The ResearchGate site also includes a user post asking for a database of data from failed experiments, a proposal I've seen before (but can't recall where). It's a great idea:

I think developing a database for the storage of failed experiments makes sense for experiments that lost the chance to be shown in published articles. Everyone could upload their experimental results which they find unsatisfactory, including the experiment method, experiment data, and the experiment purpose.

This experimental data can give a good experience and lessons to the researchers who want to perform similar experiments. They can improve their experiment based on the failing example. Someone might also give a different opinion for the unreasonable experimental data, and then test their idea. Maybe a novel theory can be developed from these failed experiments. Or, like the Post It, the unsuccessful experiment data could be used to solve other problems.